- For the Achievement Hunter edition, see Theater Mode (Achievement Hunter).
- For the Funhaus edition, see Theater Mode (Funhaus).
Theater Mode originally began as a series by Achievement Hunter in April, 2016. This show stars various Cow Chop members. Each episode contains 3-4 members of the Cow Chop cast and Let's Play guests in Season 1 Episode 5. The format is heavily inspired by the 1980-1990s show, "Mystery Science Theater 3000".
||October 20, 2017
||James Wilson, Joe, Jacob, Asher
||October 27, 2017
||Aleks Marchant, Brett Hundley, Trevor Schmidty II
||November 3, 2017
||Aleks Marchant, James Wilson, Brett Hundley, Trevor Schmidty II
||November 10, 2017
||Aleks Marchant, Joe, Asher, Jacob
||November 17, 2017
||Lindsey Washburn, Anna Marie, Elyse Willems, Autumn Farrell
||Surf Nazis Must Die
||November 24, 2017
||Aleks Marchant, Brett Hundley, Anna Marie
||December 1, 2017
||Trevor Schmidty II, Brett Hundley, Aleks Marchant
||December 8, 2017
||James Wilson, Joe, Jacob, Trevor Schmidty II