Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-198.254.172.159-20130720013048/@comment-62.90.131.82-20130825071904

Michael should have known that Edgar would be killed when he released him.

Second, the cow in which Edgar was manifested for a long time might still be alive in the recent saves. AH does destroy and re-load older saves. Even if they did save, we can't be sure that Geoff killed the old Edgar cow. There's no way we can definitively prove that said cow has been killed.